Home Up Next

Copilot Destinator Mapopolis SmartST Pro BMW Nav Notes Glossary Vote
 

PocketPC Navigation Software

Here you'll find a collection of links, reviews, notes and polls for both utilities and routing/navigation and mapping programs.
    Make sure you read about the current limitations of navigation solutions

 Discuss the contents of this page here

Index:

Overall Evaluation of programs reviewed
Navigation Software - Summary Table of Features

In House Reviews :
CoPilot

Destinator
Mapopolis Navigator
SmartST Pro
 
BMW NAV - CoPilot (preview)

Vote to Rate the Routing Quality of Navigation Programs

Random Notes
Definition of Terms

 


Overall Evaluation of programs reviewed

Navigation program
(in alphabetical order)
Short distance in town Medium (<200 miles) distance Long (>200 miles) distance:
CoPilot


"Best Highway Navigator"
B+
bullet

Fast rerouting

bullet

Fair map display

A
bullet

Excellent map management

bullet

Good Nav. Info

bullet

Routes can be tailored with waypoints

A+
bullet Excellent map management
bullet Good Nav. Info
bulletRoutes can be tailored with waypoints
Destinator C
bulletSlow rerouting
bulletPoor map display
B
(or C)
bulletFair nav.Info
bulletNo Door-to-Door if you cross a map border
B
bulletHighway maps
bulletNo long distance door to door routing
Mapopolis Navigator


"Best City Navigator"
A
bulletFast rerouting
bulletExcellent map display
B
bullet Trip planning can be difficult (load maps by county)
bulletGood Nav. Info
B
(or D)
bulletTrip planning can be difficult (load maps by county)
bulletSometimes impossible to plan full trip
SmartST Pro B-
bulletSlow rerouting
bulletGood map display
B
bulletExcellent nav info
bulletGood map management
bulletRoutes not always optimal
B
(or D)
bulletExcellent nav info
bulletSometimes impossible to plan full trip
bulletRoutes not always optimal



Navigation Software

Name Price 7 Vers.# Type
4
Coverage Routing
Quality 5

*VOTE*
Map
Source
Main Features Review
Nav. Info 1 Re-route Voice 3 Stops Highway
Maps
8
Points of
interest
Map
Mgmt6
Avoid
Detour
 
Alturion 399/s
599/b
Beta ? R/S Europe ?/ TeleAtlas DTN ? WAV No ? Yes ? ? Preview
CoPilot $299/b
$349/b
3.0 R/S USA
U.K.
A/A Propr. DTN
DTA
ETA
Auto TTS/
WAV
Yes Yes
Good
Yes CUST CODE Yes
Here
Destinator $142/m
$249/s
$329/b
1.72 R/S N.A.
Europe
Israel
A/B NavTech DTN
ETA
Auto WAV No Yes
Good
Yes
Good
REG2
CODE
No Here
Distefora 599 1.1 R/S Germany
Alps
? TeleAtlas ETA Auto ? ? ? ? ? ? External
German
ID Navigator 99 1.2 R/S France C/C TeleAtlas ? Auto TTS No Yes Yes REG1
RAM
? -
Mapopolis
Navigator
$90 3.03 R/S USA
Canada (major cities)
B/B NavTech DTN
DTA
ETA
TOA
Auto WAV No No Yes
Good
(with Guides)
COUN
RAM
No Here
Mapviewer 60 2.02 R/S France
Benelux
C/C TeleAtlas None Auto No No No ? CUST
RAM
No Notes
SmartST Europe 211/s
272/s
€579/b
Beta R/S Europe ? NavTech DTN
DTA
ETA
TIM
SPE
HDG
Auto WAV No No Yes REG2
SEAM
? -
SmartST USA $179/s
$300/b
1.0 R/S USA B/ NavTech DTN
DTA
ETA
TIM
SPE
HDG
Auto WAV No No Yes REG2
SEAM
?
Here
Pharos Ostia $69/s
$194/b
$229/b
3.x
4.0
R/S N.A. B/B TeleAtlas DTN
DTA in 4.0
Auto WAV No Yes
Limited
Yes
Very Poor
in 4.0 too
REG1
RAM
No Preview
of 4.0
PocketMap Navigator $80/s
$230/b
Beta R/S USA ? ? DFS
DTN
DTA
Manual TTS Yes No Yes
Excellent
COUN
RAM
Yes Discuss in the
Forums
Teletype $95/s
$299/b
09
2002a
R/S
M/T
N.A.
Europe
C/D TeleAtlas DTN
DTA
+ custom
Manual TTS/
WAV
Yes
(lost on reroute)
Yes,
Limited
Yes COUN
RAM
No
Notes
TomTom Citymaps 2 60 1.1 R/S Europe
(large cities)
C/C TeleAtlas DTN
DTA
ETA *
No No Yes No Yes CITY
RAM
Yes External
Notes
TomTom Navigator $129/s
$429/b

note
1.41
(main)
1.40
(GPS)
R/S Europe
sold by
country
B/A TeleAtlas DTN
DTA
ETA
SPE
Auto WAV No No
(country)
Yes
Fair
REG1
REG2
CTRY
CODE
Yes External
Notes
TomTom Online € 5/
month
Online R/S Europe ? TeleAtlas DTN
DTA
ETA *
No No No n/a Yes
Good
n/a ? External
Notes
TomTom RoutePlanner 2 $35 2.12
3.1
Road N.A.
Europe
A/A ? DTA
ETA *
No No Yes n/a No REG2
RAM
Yes Here
Notes
Xmap Handheld $40 2.0 R/S/T USA C/C Propr. ? No Beep Yes No Yes CUST
RAM
No Notes


1  Navigation Information provided by the program:
    DFS - Distance From Start
    DTN - Distance to Next
    DTA - Distance to Arrival
    ETN  - Estimated Time to Next
    ETA  - Estimated Time to Arrival
    TOA - Time of Arrival
    SPE   - Speed
    HDG - Heading
    TIM - Time

2  CityMaps is also known as  Smartpath City when bundled with the Navman iPaq sleeve in Europe
    RoutePlanner is also known as  Smartpath Trip when bundled with the Navman iPaq sleeve in Europe

3  "WAV" means that it will provide a human pre-recorded voice guidance, i.e. 2 miles to next turn, 500 yards to next turn, etc...
    "TTS" (Text To Speech) means that it will spell out the next turn using a synthesized voice, i.e. In 2 miles, turn on Winchester Avenue
    - While the synthesized options appears more interesting, bear in mind that it will often sound like a "computer voice" and may be harder to
       understand than a pre-recorded human voice. I think the recorded voice is generally sufficient.

4  R: Road - S: Street - T: Topo - M: Marine

5  First rating shows my evaluation, second one as voted by this site's visitors

6  Map management:
   CITY - City level
   COUN - County level maps in the US (see here for number of counties per state) about 40 for California !
   CTRY - Maps by region - country, Europe  
   CUST - Custom map created on a desktop/laptop from a database on a CD/HD. Convenient but make sure you've got the right maps before you leave !  
   REG1 - Maps Loaded by region - small regions, 8/10 per state in the US and 2 per province in Europe
   REG2 - Maps Loaded by region - large regions,  2 max per state in the US and 1 per province in Europe 
   RAM - Maps loaded in RAM, improves access speed but limits area that can be downloaded at the same time. Maps are stitched for seamless transitions
   CODE - Compression/Decompression on the fly - allows loading of large maps, but can slow down display, increase CPU usage and reduce battery life
   SEAM - Maps are not loaded, they just have to be present on a memory card and any info can be accessed

7   /m: Maps Only        /s: Software + Maps         /b: hardware/software bundle

8   This is important if you intend to do long distance routing, state/state or cross country.

  



 

Home Up Next