Here you'll find a collection of links, reviews, notes and polls for both utilities and routing/navigation and mapping programs.
Make sure you read about the current limitations of navigation solutions
Discuss the contents of this page here
Index:
Overall Evaluation of programs reviewed
Navigation Software - Summary Table of Features
In House Reviews :
CoPilot
Destinator
Mapopolis Navigator
SmartST Pro
BMW NAV - CoPilot (preview)
Vote to Rate the Routing Quality of Navigation Programs
Random Notes
Definition of Terms
![]()
Overall Evaluation of programs
reviewed
|
Navigation program (in alphabetical order) |
Short distance in town | Medium (<200 miles) distance | Long (>200 miles) distance: | |||||||||||||||||||
|
CoPilot "Best Highway Navigator" |
B+ |
|
A |
| A+ |
|
||||||||||||||||
| Destinator | C |
|
B (or C) |
| B |
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Mapopolis
Navigator "Best City Navigator" |
A |
|
B |
|
B (or D) |
|
||||||||||||||||
| SmartST Pro | B- |
|
B |
|
B (or D) |
|
||||||||||||||||
| Name | Price 7 | Vers.# |
Type 4 |
Coverage |
Routing Quality 5 *VOTE* |
Map Source |
Main Features | Review | |||||||
| Nav. Info 1 | Re-route | Voice 3 | Stops |
Highway Maps 8 |
Points of interest |
Map Mgmt6 |
Avoid Detour |
||||||||
| Alturion |
€399/s €599/b |
Beta ? | R/S | Europe | ?/ | TeleAtlas | DTN | ? | WAV | No | ? | Yes | ? | ? | Preview |
| CoPilot |
$299/b $349/b |
3.0 | R/S | USA U.K. |
A/A | Propr. |
DTN DTA ETA |
Auto |
TTS/ WAV |
Yes |
Yes Good |
Yes | CUST CODE | Yes | Here |
| Destinator |
$142/m $249/s $329/b |
1.72 | R/S | N.A. Europe Israel |
A/B | NavTech |
DTN ETA |
Auto | WAV | No |
Yes Good |
Yes Good |
REG2 CODE |
No | Here |
| Distefora | €599 | 1.1 | R/S | Germany Alps |
? | TeleAtlas | ETA | Auto | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
External German |
| ID Navigator | €99 | 1.2 | R/S | France | C/C | TeleAtlas | ? | Auto | TTS | No | Yes | Yes | REG1 RAM |
? | - |
|
Mapopolis Navigator |
$90 | 3.03 | R/S |
USA Canada (major cities) |
B/B | NavTech | DTN DTA ETA TOA |
Auto | WAV | No | No | Yes Good (with Guides) |
COUN RAM |
No | Here |
| Mapviewer | €60 | 2.02 | R/S | France Benelux |
C/C | TeleAtlas | None | Auto | No | No | No | ? | CUST RAM |
No | Notes |
| SmartST Europe |
€211/s €272/s €579/b |
Beta | R/S | Europe | ? | NavTech | DTN DTA ETA TIM SPE HDG |
Auto | WAV | No | No | Yes | REG2 SEAM |
? | - |
| SmartST USA |
$179/s $300/b |
1.0 | R/S | USA | B/ | NavTech | DTN DTA ETA TIM SPE HDG |
Auto | WAV | No | No | Yes | REG2 SEAM |
? |
Here |
| Pharos Ostia |
$69/s $194/b $229/b |
3.x 4.0 |
R/S | N.A. | B/B | TeleAtlas | DTN DTA in 4.0 |
Auto | WAV | No | Yes Limited |
Yes Very Poor in 4.0 too |
REG1 RAM |
No |
Preview of 4.0 |
| PocketMap Navigator |
$80/s $230/b |
Beta | R/S | USA | ? | ? | DFS DTN DTA |
Manual | TTS | Yes | No | Yes Excellent |
COUN RAM |
Yes |
Discuss in the Forums |
| Teletype |
$95/s $299/b |
09 2002a |
R/S M/T |
N.A. Europe |
C/D | TeleAtlas | DTN DTA + custom |
Manual |
TTS/ WAV |
Yes (lost on reroute) |
Yes, Limited |
Yes | COUN RAM |
No | Notes |
| TomTom Citymaps 2 | €60 | 1.1 | R/S | Europe (large cities) |
C/C | TeleAtlas | DTN DTA ETA * |
No | No | Yes | No | Yes | CITY RAM |
Yes |
External Notes |
| TomTom Navigator |
$129/s $429/b note |
1.41 (main) 1.40 (GPS) |
R/S | Europe sold by country |
B/A | TeleAtlas | DTN DTA ETA SPE |
Auto | WAV | No | No (country) |
Yes Fair |
REG1 REG2 CTRY CODE |
Yes |
External Notes |
| TomTom Online |
€ 5/ month |
Online | R/S | Europe | ? | TeleAtlas | DTN DTA ETA * |
No | No | No | n/a |
Yes Good |
n/a | ? |
External Notes |
| TomTom RoutePlanner 2 | $35 |
2.12 3.1 |
Road | N.A. Europe |
A/A | ? | DTA ETA * |
No | No | Yes | n/a | No | REG2 RAM |
Yes | Here Notes |
| Xmap Handheld | $40 | 2.0 | R/S/T | USA | C/C | Propr. | ? | No | Beep | Yes | No | Yes | CUST RAM |
No | Notes |
|
3
"WAV" means that it will provide a human
pre-recorded voice guidance, i.e. 2 miles to next turn, 500 yards to next
turn, etc... 4 R: Road - S: Street - T: Topo - M: Marine 5 First rating shows my evaluation, second one as voted by this site's visitors 6
Map management: 8 This is important if you intend to do long distance routing, state/state or cross country. |
|||||||||||||||